Pocket Pours Flavor Guide: Which Coffee Syrup Should You Try First?

One of the questions I get asked most is some version of "which flavor should I try first?" So here's the honest breakdown, packet by packet, including what each one actually tastes best in.

Vanilla Bean

The one that works with everything. If you're new to flavored coffee syrup, start here. It's smooth, not overly sweet, and works in hot coffee, iced coffee, cold brew, or even stirred into oatmeal. Pairs especially well with cinnamon or a splash of oat milk if you want something creamier.

Caramel

Rich and a little indulgent without tipping into candy territory. This is the one people reach for on slower mornings or when they want their coffee to feel like a treat. Try it in a cold brew with ice for an easy homemade caramel iced coffee.

Hazelnut

A classic for a reason. Nutty, warm, and it holds up well in both hot and iced drinks. If you like a European-style coffeehouse flavor, this is your packet.

Brown Sugar Cinnamon

This one's become a favorite for fall and winter, but honestly it works year-round. Think snickerdoodle energy in your coffee cup. Great in a latte, and it plays really well with oat or almond milk.

Lavender

The most distinctive flavor in the lineup. Floral, a little unexpected, and it turns an ordinary latte into something that tastes like it came from a specialty café. If you've never had a lavender latte, this is the packet that will make you understand the hype.

Coconut

Tropical and light. Best in iced coffee or cold brew, especially in the summer. Pairs naturally with a little bit of caramel if you want a coconut-caramel combo.

Sugar-Free line: SF Vanilla, SF Caramel, SF Hazelnut

Same flavor direction as the classics, made with sucralose instead of sugar so you get the taste without the calories. These are a good fit if you're keto, watching sugar intake, or just prefer a lighter option. Each packet is still dosed for one 16oz cup, so the dosing habit doesn't change even if the ingredients do.

Building your own variety pack

If you can't decide, that's what the variety packs are for. The Classic Variety Pack (Vanilla Bean, Caramel, Brown Sugar Cinnamon) covers the three most popular everyday flavors. The Sugar-Free Variety Pack covers all three SF options if you want to try the lighter line before committing to a full bag of one flavor.

Not sure where to start? [Shop the full flavor lineup →]